Facebook Pixel




What makes Cedar Crest Ice Cream different is we make the kind of ice cream we would eat everyday. It’s the ice cream we would buy and serve to our friends and family.  In fact, when we started the business, we looked at every ice cream being made and compared what was available with our own vision for what a great, Wisconsin ice cream should taste like. What we make now, the small batch, premium quality ice cream you can buy today is the very same recipe that we developed back then.

At Cedar Crest the ice cream business is the only business we’re in, so our level of commitment is really high. And with our craft ice cream philosophy, our processes are all centered on making small batches that give the ice cream more flavor and creaminess. A flavor and creaminess that we think is unsurpassed in the ice cream business, and we sincerely hope you agree.

Did you know we invented ‘tracks’ in ice cream? Sure, you see it everywhere today, but Elephant Tracks® was the first of its kind in the market. Since then, we’ve created some of the most exciting flavors and names in the business. Names like Caramel Collision®, Coconut Explosion, Super Madness and Lady Bug® just to name a few. We offer over 80 flavors of ice cream, with yearly Feature Flavors that offer truly unique and exciting ice cream experiences. 


You're in the smile business! Select from our wide variety of flavors that will keep your guests coming back again and again. Also make sure you look at the featured flavors that Cedar Crest has to offer. Here is a list of the 3 gallon tubs that we carry.

Item #552221 - Ice Cream Birthday Cake - Yellow Cake Flavored Ice Cream blended with Cake Pieces and Sprinkled with Multi-Colored Candy Pieces.

Item #554183 - Ice Cream Black Cherry - Black Cherry Flavored Ice Cream with Black Cherries.

Item #554031 - Ice Cream Blue Moon - Blue Ice Cream with an Almond Flavor.

Item #552020 - Ice Cream Bubble Gum - Pieces of Bubble Gum in Pink Bubble Gum Flavored Ice Cream.

Item #554037 - Ice Cream Butter Pecan - Butter Pecan Flavored Ice Cream with Pecans.

Item #553993 - Ice Cream Caramel Collision - Caramel Ice Cream with a Caramel Swirl and Chocolate Coated Caramel Mini Cups.

Item #554070 - Ice Cream Choclate Chip Chookie Dough - Cookie Dough Pieces and Chocolate Chip blended in a Cookie Dough Flavored Ice Cream.

Item #552036 - Ice Cream Chocolate Peanut Butter Swirl - Chocolate Icea Cream with a Peanut Butter Swirl.

Item #553129 - Ice Cream Chocolate - Chocolate Ice Cream.

Item #552257 - Ice Cream Coconut Explosion - Coconut Flavored Ice Cream with Chocolate Covered Coconut Pieces, Coconut Flakes, and Chocolate Covered Almonds.

Item #554099 - Ice Cream Cookies N Cream - Crushed Cookies Blended in Creamy Vanilla Ice Cream.

Item #552256 - Ice Cream Cotton Candy - Cotton Candy Flavored Ice Cream with a Cotton Candy Swirl.

Item #554152 - Ice Cream Elephant Tracks - Pieces of Peanut Butter Cups and Chocolate Fudge Swirled in Chocolate Ice Cream.

Item #552100 - Ice Cream Lady Bug - Vanilla Ice Cream with Chocolate and Caramel Swirls and Pecans.

Item #554009 - Ice Cream Mac Island Fudge - Vanilla Ice Cream with Chewy Fudge Pieces and Swirled with Butter Fudge Sauce.

Item #552107 - Ice Cream Maple Nut - Maple Flavored Ice Cream with Walnuts.

Item #554131 - Ice Cream Mint Chocolate Chip - Green Mint Flavored Ice Cream with Chocolate Chips.

Item #553197 - Ice Cream Pirates Bounty - M&M's Chocolate Candies and Chocolate Sandwich Cookies in Caramel Flavored Ice Cream.

Item #552472 - ICe Cream Strawberry Cheese Cake - Cheesecake Flavored Ice Cream with a Strawberry Swirl.

Item #554189 - Ice Cream Strawberry - Strawberry Flavored Ice Cream Swirled with Real Strawberries.

Item #552477 - Ice Cream Superman - Blue Raspberry, Cherry, and Vanilla Flavored Ice Cream.

Item #553010 - Ice Cream Vanilla 

Item #553230 - Ice Cream Zanzibar - Dark Chocolate Flavored Ice Cream.

Item #502605 - Sherbert Rainbow - Lime, Orange, and Raspberry Flavored Sherberts Swirled Together.


These are the featured flavors that Cedar Crest has for the year. These are flavors that you can get however they have to be

pre-booked with your sales consultant.


Sea Turtle  #3414 - Chocolate Ice Cream with a Salty Caramel Ribbon with Pecans.

Firecracker #3345 - Strawberry flavored ice cream with Pop Rock Candies.


Big Muddy #3312 - Dark Chocolate Ice Cream with a Caramel Swirl and Brownie pieces.

Cupcake #3331 - Chocolate Cake flavored ice cream with a Creamy White Frosting swirl and chunks of Chocolate Cake Pieces.


Deep Dish Apple Pie #3336 - Cinnamon Crunch in Apple Ice Cream with an Apple swirl.

Monster Cookie Dough #3382 - Oatmeal Cookie Dough and M&M's in Cookie Dough Ice Cream.


Pumpkin Pie # 3396 - Pieces of Pie Crust blended in Pumpkin flavored Ice Cream.


Quarter Back Sneak #3399 - Nougat flavored Ice Cream with Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Footballs and a Caramel swirl.


Snowflake #3410 - White Pistachio Ice Cream blened with a flurry of White Chocolate coated Almonds and White Chocolate Flakes.

Peppermint Stick # 3192 - Vanilla Ice Cream with Red and Green Peppermint Candy.

Egg Nog #3342 - Egg Nog flavored Ice Cream.